MercuryGate vs SAP Transportation Management

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared MercuryGate vs SAP Transportation Management based on data from our 400+ point analysis of TMS Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Product Basics

MercuryGate is a global transportation management system that can handle all modes of delivery. This software package comes with architecture that makes it easy to integrate with other platforms, including those for WMS and ERP. Plan, optimize and execute stock movements through a single-platform.

This platform provides high-level visibility into all tasks and helps quickly locate suitable carriers to transport stock. As your operation grows in response to the global transportation market, this application contains functionality to scale up to fit more complex requirements.
read more...
This SAP transportation management platform features both on-premise and cloud-based deployment styles. Features a number of tools focused on increasing end-to-end efficiency and increased visibility. Operations can leverage forecasting tools in order to effectively plan ahead for a range of transport processes while gaining valuable insight into project-wide data.

This application provides collaboration features to enhance communication with partners and clients. Automation tools optimize processes that normally require a large investment of manual resources.
read more...
$10,000 Annually
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$800,000 Quote-based
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Track and Manage Claims: Tackle claims, such as loss and damage, overcharge and return authorizations, by automating claim form generation and payment calculations. This efficiency reduces managerial burdens, cuts errors and brings visibility into claims, timely incident reporting and improved cash flow. This expansive toolset cements MercuryGate as our best system for claims management.
  • Choose Multimodal Transport and Negotiate Rates: Ship freight through transportation methods, like parcel, truckload, rail, air and intermodal, that all score a perfect 100 in our analyst data. MercuryGate also takes home top marks for carrier performance scorecards that evaluate carriers and a freight audit payment (FAP) functionality for auditing carrier bills against approved rates.
  • Gain Visibility: Gain complete visibility into critical transportation processes. The track-and-trace feature scored a 100 as it alerts you each time a package or pallet's barcode is scanned or its status is changed manually during the consignment process. Delivery ETA is another visibility feature that scores a perfect 100 for calculating the ETA of each truckload or LTL shipment.
  • Stay on Top of Global Regulations: Ensure compliance with global trade regulations in your multi-leg and multimodal shipments. Access multiple languages, currencies and units of measure to keep your firm running smoothly despite common barriers between nations. MercuryGate takes care of driver, carrier and trade compliance, thus scoring 100 across these features.
  • Simplify Reporting: Gain visibility into the shipping and access historical data with customizable reporting and dashboards that were rated 100 by our analysts. Optimize operations by improving asset management and identifying cost-saving opportunities. Mitigate risks proactively by centralizing and automating risk monitoring.
read more...
  • Increase Productivity: SAP TMS contains helpful process automation that can take care of transportation requirements while freeing employees up for more vital tasks. 
  • Better Visibility: Tracking and tracing tools allow users to keep a constant eye on the progress of their shipments. Cross-system document flow and data-driven rate negotiation help give users a competitive edge. 
  • Standardized Logistics: Centralized data and rate management tools share a common platform that is easy to integrate, deploy and access by users. 
  • Improved Cash-Flow: Settling costs with accurate tools can reduce overcharges and lessen invoicing errors. SAP TMS has tools that can automate accrual generation, charge tracking and auditing. 
  • Quicker Decision Making: Agile reporting tools in SAP TMS allow users to assess freight costs and evaluate transportation intelligence. Graphical displays make this information easily digestible and interactive dashboards give users an easy-to-use area to access important data. 
read more...
  • 3PL Support: MercuryGate, while suitable for most companies, includes functionalities to help 3PL providers run the operations they are in charge of. Manage multiple transportation methods for multiple clients with a suite of 3PL-enabled tools. It scores 100 in our analyst data for integrating with freight broker solutions such as Loadsmart and FreightFriend. The same impressive score expands to its integration with logistics solutions like FedEx and UPS.
  • MercuryGate Control Tower: The control tower's map-view interface offers a complete overview of all shipments in transit. It helps users identify bottlenecks or delays and take corrective actions promptly. The control tower improves situational awareness and operational responsiveness.
  • Order Management: MercuryGate's TMS simplifies order management with automated order entry, a shipping cart for item selection and electronic generation of all shipping documents, including invoices and bills of lading. Rated a score of 100, its features let you access agreement details, plan loads by weight or delivery dates, and drill into vendor shipment progress.
  • Exception Management: The system highlights important deviations from routine operations, such as delays and unexpected costs, enabling quick resolution to maintain efficiency and service levels. Instant notifications ensure all relevant parties are aware and can collaborate on solutions, reducing misunderstandings and maintaining alignment across the logistics network.
  • Carrier Rate Management: This module helps you compare freight rates and services from different carriers to make cost-effective shipping decisions while maintaining service levels. Use performance scorecards that score a perfect 100 in our data to evaluate carriers based on criteria such as timeliness, compliance and responsiveness.
  • Reporting and Analytics: The platform offers customizable reports that create insights specific to operational requirements, enabling targeted analysis and strategic planning. The financial and performance analysis reports that score 100 in our analyst data offer in-depth breakdowns of costs and operational metrics.
read more...
  • Freight Management: SAP TMS contains a suite of tools that can lower spending on transportation management processes while measuring shipper and trade agreement compliances. 
  • Order Management: Visibility into shipping and order management helps increase customer satisfaction while also cutting costs related to freight management. SAP TMS boosts the efficiency of order and process management while leveraging rules-based routing. 
  • Analytics: Analytics tools allow SAP TMS to provide real-time data-driven data in order to help optimize and expedite planning processes. With tools to improve collaboration with business partners while also lowering data complexity, this solution helps keep an operation competitive. 
  • Transportation Management: Streamlined transportation management processes allow logistics operations to move faster while creating a more responsive supply chain. Dynamically responding transportation processes cut costs even further while boosting efficiency. 
  • Freight Costing: Increase visibility into your transportation costing and invoicing. Automated calculations help cut down on human-based errors and clients can integrate their transportation management data into their billing data. 
  • Planning: Planning tools increase order delivery accuracy and boost on-time deliveries. Plan out the most fuel-efficient transport route and leverage automated planning processes to connect with the perfect carrier. 
read more...

Product Ranking

#1

among all
TMS Software

#4

among all
TMS Software

Find out who the leaders are

Analyst Rating Summary

83
85
88
81
80
57
74
94
Show More Show More
Reporting and dashboards
Freight Rating and Multimodal Transport
Integration and Extensibility
Claims Management
Transportation Order Management
Dock Scheduling and Yard Management
Freight Rating and Multimodal Transport
Integration and Extensibility
Reporting and dashboards

Analyst Ratings for Functional Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

MercuryGate
SAP Transportation Management
+ Add Product + Add Product
Claims Management Compliance And Governance Dock Scheduling And Yard Management Freight Rating And Multimodal Transport Mobile Reporting And Dashboards Transportation Order Management Transportation Sourcing And Procurement 88 80 74 90 64 98 82 59 81 57 94 93 50 88 98 87 0 25 50 75 100
90%
0%
10%
84%
5%
11%
80%
0%
20%
60%
0%
40%
80%
0%
20%
100%
0%
0%
92%
0%
8%
83%
17%
0%
67%
0%
33%
50%
0%
50%
100%
0%
0%
88%
0%
12%
83%
0%
17%
100%
0%
0%
63%
0%
37%
100%
0%
0%

Analyst Ratings for Technical Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

90%
0%
10%
90%
0%
10%

User Sentiment Summary

Great User Sentiment 128 reviews
Great User Sentiment 27 reviews
83%
of users recommend this product

MercuryGate has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 83% when considering 128 user reviews from 3 recognized software review sites.

83%
of users recommend this product

SAP Transportation Management has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 83% when considering 27 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.

4.0 (16)
3.8 (4)
3.5 (16)
4.5 (6)
4.3 (96)
4.2 (12)
n/a
3.8 (5)

Awards

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated MercuryGate and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Claims Management and Integration and Extensibility.

Claims Management Award
Integration and Extensibility Award

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated SAP Transportation Management and concluded it deserves the award for the Best Overall TMS Software available today and earns best-in-class honors for Dock Scheduling and Yard Management, Transportation Order Management, Transportation Sourcing and Procurement and Integration and Extensibility.

Analysts' Pick Award
Dock Scheduling and Yard Management Award
Transportation Order Management Award
Transportation Sourcing and Procurement Award
Integration and Extensibility Award

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

Cost Savings: These systems can optimize routing and carrier selection, leading to reduced fuel expenses and improved delivery efficiency, resulting in significant cost savings for businesses.
Real-Time Visibility: TMS solutions provide GPS integration and real-time tracking capabilities for monitoring shipments and receiving timely updates, enhancing customer service.
Greater Efficiency: A TMS can automate load planning, shipment tracking, and documentation management, reducing manual work and errors to speed up delivery times and improve operational efficiency.
Show more
Improved Visibility: Provides real-time insights into transportation processes, allowing for better decision-making and proactive problem-solving.
Enhanced Efficiency: Automates manual tasks, streamlines workflows, and optimizes resource allocation, leading to cost savings and improved productivity.
Collaboration: Facilitates seamless collaboration between shippers, carriers, and other stakeholders, fostering stronger relationships and improving communication.
Scalability: Adapts to changing business needs and supports growth, ensuring long-term value and flexibility.
Show more
High Implementation Costs: Buying and implementing a TMS can be costly, including expenses for software and hardware and potential disruptions during the shift from legacy systems.
Complex Implementation Process: Poor planning or lack of standardization can lead to failed performances. If the chosen TMS doesn’t align with the company’s needs, it can create further inefficiencies.
Limited Flexibility: Some TMS solutions may have limitations in terms of customization and flexibility, making it difficult to adapt to specific business needs or changes in the market.
Show more
Complexity: The system's intricate structure and extensive configuration options can present a steep learning curve for new users, potentially leading to implementation challenges and delays.
Cost: Implementing and maintaining SAP TM can be expensive, especially for smaller businesses or those with less complex transportation needs. The licensing fees, infrastructure costs, and ongoing support expenses can accumulate quickly.
Integration: Integrating SAP TM with existing systems, such as ERP or warehouse management systems, can be a complex and time-consuming process, requiring careful planning and execution to ensure seamless data flow and avoid disruptions to operations.
Customization: While SAP TM offers a high degree of customization, tailoring the system to specific business requirements can be challenging and may necessitate specialized expertise or additional development efforts.
Show more

MercuryGate has attracted a range of users, from small businesses to large enterprises, each with unique needs and expectations. The platform's user-friendly interface has consistently been lauded, making it accessible even for those with limited technical expertise. This ease of use translates into tangible efficiency gains, as users report spending less time on administrative tasks and more time focusing on core business activities.My firsthand experience with the platform involved a complex, multi-leg shipment of industrial pipes from China to a remote rig site in North Dakota. This scenario tested MercuryGate's capabilities across multiple transportation modes, including trucks, ocean freight and rail. The TMS efficiently handled the complexities of this shipment, showcasing its potential for cost savings and operational efficiency.During execution, the load board provided real-time visibility into all 17 loads involved in the shipment. This centralized information hub allowed me to proactively manage the shipment, identify potential bottlenecks and make informed decisions. The 'next recommended activity' feature was particularly useful in streamlining operations and ensuring timely execution.Furthermore, MercuryGate's carrier and rate selection capabilities stood out. The platform provided a detailed overview of available carriers and rates, empowering me to make informed decisions based on cost, transit time, carrier reliability and contractual agreements.In addition to these core functionalities, MercuryGate offers industry-specific features, 3PL support, a control tower for enhanced visibility, exception management for proactive issue resolution, scheduling capabilities, and robust reporting and analytics tools.Ultimately, MercuryGate is best suited for businesses seeking a reliable and easy-to-use transportation and logistics management solution that can accommodate a wide range of needs. Its intuitive interface and comprehensive features make it an ideal choice for those looking to streamline their operations and improve efficiency without the need for extensive customization.

Show more

Navigating the intricate world of transportation management systems can feel like charting a course through a dense jungle. With a myriad of options available, each boasting unique features and functionalities, selecting the right one for your business can be daunting. One name that consistently emerges from the undergrowth is SAP Transportation Management, a comprehensive solution designed to streamline and optimize transportation operations. But how does it truly fare in the eyes of its users? SAP Transportation Management receives consistent praise for its user-friendly interface, making it accessible even for those without prior experience with similar software. The system's ability to seamlessly integrate with existing enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems is another highlight, enabling a unified view of logistics and supply chain processes. This integration empowers businesses to break down data silos and achieve greater visibility across their operations. However, some users note that the initial setup and configuration can be complex, often requiring specialized expertise. Additionally, the software's robust capabilities come at a cost, which may pose a challenge for smaller businesses with limited budgets. Despite these drawbacks, SAP Transportation Management stands out for its comprehensive reporting and analytics features, providing businesses with actionable insights to drive informed decision-making and optimize transportation strategies. The software's ability to manage various transportation modes, including road, rail, air, and ocean, further enhances its versatility and appeal. In conclusion, SAP Transportation Management emerges as a powerful and adaptable solution well-suited for large enterprises with complex transportation needs and the resources to invest in a sophisticated system. Its ability to integrate with existing systems, provide end-to-end visibility, and generate comprehensive reports makes it a valuable asset for businesses seeking to optimize their transportation operations and gain a competitive edge in today's dynamic market. While the initial setup complexity and cost may present challenges for smaller businesses, the long-term benefits and scalability of SAP Transportation Management make it a worthwhile investment for those looking to elevate their transportation management to new heights.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in TMS Software


3Gtms

Alpega TMS

AscendTMS

C.H. Robinson

E2open

FreightPOP

Kuebix

Luminate Logistics

Manhattan TMS

Oracle Transportation Management

PCS

RateLinx

SAP Transportation Management

Shipwell

Uber Freight

Related Categories

Head-to-Head Comparison

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
Table settings