Our analysts compared Paychex vs Payroll City based on data from our 400+ point analysis of Payroll Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.
Analyst Rating
User Sentiment
Payroll City is a comprehensive software solution designed to streamline payroll management and related tasks. It is particularly well-suited for small to medium-sized businesses seeking an efficient and reliable way to handle payroll processing, tax calculations, and compliance requirements. The software offers a range of benefits, including automated payroll calculations, direct deposit capabilities, and detailed reporting features. Users appreciate its intuitive interface and robust customer support, which make it easier to navigate complex payroll tasks.
Popular features of Payroll City include employee self-service portals, time and attendance tracking, and customizable payroll reports. These features help businesses save time and reduce errors, enhancing overall operational efficiency. Compared to similar products, Payroll City is often praised for its user-friendly design and comprehensive functionality, making it a preferred choice for many organizations.
Pricing details for Payroll City are not readily available, and it is recommended that users contact SelectHub for a personalized pricing quote based on their specific needs. This approach ensures that businesses receive a tailored solution that fits their budget and requirements.
among all Payroll Software
Paychex has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 83% when considering 2800 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.
Payroll City has a 'excellent' User Satisfaction Rating of 95% when considering 15 user reviews from 1 recognized software review sites.
SelectHub research analysts have evaluated Paychex and concluded it deserves the award for the Best Overall Payroll Software available today and earns best-in-class honors for Expense Management and Platform Capabilities.
Payroll City stands above the rest by achieving an ‘Excellent’ rating as a User Favorite.
Paychex incorporates a range of different solutions and is used widely by small, medium and large-sized companies. While around 40% of users were happy with the functionality of the system, the majority expressed dissatisfaction with its tax capabilities, pricing and customer service. Many described it as dishonest and complained especially that they were oversold on its capabilities and that the salespeople used pushy tactics to try and upsell them. Other complaints of the system included making errors, overpaying employees or even miscalculating taxes resulting in serious penalties. Current and former clients greatly disliked the service. The UI was the most positively reviewed element of the platform with around 80% expressing satisfaction with the design and navigation. Around 50% were happy with the pricing structure and a minority of around 30% of users said they had positive experiences with some select customer service members. This disparity in experiences may be in part to the high turnover rate in representatives which is mentioned many times during the reviews. This solution could be appropriate for small and medium-sized businesses. It supports larger enterprises, but buyers should make sure it has the necessary functionality before purchasing.
Is Payroll City the key to unlocking simplified payroll management? Users seem to think so! Payroll City generally receives positive reviews, with users praising its user-friendly interface and responsive customer service. One user raved about the platform's ability to "talk" to their accounting software, highlighting the seamless integration with other systems like ERP and timekeeping, which sets it apart from competitors that suffer from data loss during transfers. This ease of use, coupled with robust features, makes handling complex payroll tasks a breeze. However, some users expressed a desire for more advanced reporting features, indicating room for improvement. A standout feature of Payroll City is its exceptional customer support. Users consistently commend the knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful staff who go above and beyond to provide solutions and address concerns. One user even exclaimed, "Ask for [rep's name], she is the best!!!", showcasing the personalized assistance provided. While a few users mentioned occasional miscommunications with customer service, these instances appear to be rare. Overall, Payroll City excels in its simplicity, making it ideal for small to medium-sized businesses seeking a reliable and efficient payroll solution. The platform's intuitive design, coupled with exceptional customer support, ensures a smooth and hassle-free payroll experience, freeing up businesses to focus on what matters most – growth and success.
WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...