Home > Manufacturing Software > xTuple > xTuple vs QAD ERP

xTuple vs QAD ERP

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared xTuple vs QAD ERP based on data from our 400+ point analysis of Manufacturing Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Overview Pricing Benefits & Features User Ratings Analyst Summary Screenshots
xTuple Software Tool
QAD ERP Software Tool
Get Free Demo Demo    Request Pricing Pricing
Get Free Demo Demo    Request Pricing Pricing

Product Basics

xTuple is an operations management solution for small and mid-sized businesses. It gives managers visibility into processes and inventory. It drives sustainable profitability by driving efficiency across all operational tiers. Users can eliminate redundant tasks, data and human error. It also automates accounts receivables and payables, analyzes costs and manages inventory.

Its solutions are suitable for businesses in the biomed and pharmaceutical, electronics manufacturing, food processing, machinery and equipment and metal fabrication industries. It works with distributors and manufacturers in multiple industries and tiers of operational complexity.
read more...
QAD ERP is a comprehensive manufacturing software solution designed to streamline and integrate core business processes across manufacturing organizations. It's particularly well-suited for mid-sized to large manufacturers in industries such as automotive, consumer products, food and beverage, life sciences, and industrial equipment. Key benefits include improved visibility and control over operations, enhanced collaboration, and boosted productivity. Popular features encompass financial management, supply chain management, production planning, inventory management, quality management, and customer relationship management. According to user experiences, QAD ERP stands out for its deep industry-specific capabilities, user-friendly interface, and strong customer support. Pricing is typically based on a per-user, per-month subscription model, with costs varying depending on the number of users, modules, and deployment options.

Pros
  • Industry-specific features
  • User-friendly interface
  • Strong customer support
  • Improved visibility and control
  • Enhanced collaboration
 Cons
  • Complex implementation
  • High customization costs
  • Steeper learning curve
  • Limited reporting capabilities
  • Potential integration challenges
read more...
$175 Monthly
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$5,000/User, Monthly
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Accelerated Onboarding: Streamlines and accelerates the onboarding process. Users can implement core essentials within 90 days. Supports process mapping and customized pilot sessions, guided and customized onboarding, preliminary data migration and dedicated support.  
  • Operations Process Workflow: Handles operational workflows by helping users manage floor transactions like material issuing and returns, scrap, shop floor workbench, post operation, operation posting, post production and closing work orders.
  • Tax Management: Manage taxes by streamlining tax zones, authorities, classes, codes, types, assignments and registrations. Integrates with Avalara for better tax processing. No need to search for sales tax rates.  
  • Reliable Tax Calculations: Sends transaction details to AvaTax, and AvaTax sends the tax total back to xTuple. Supports updates when tax regulations change. Lets salespersons, customers and managers view owed taxes at any time.  
  • Integrations: Integrates with QuickBooks and works in tandem with distributors and manufacturers across multiple levels of complexity and industries. Manages inventory, helps with materials requirements planning, sales and CRM, KPI dashboards, manufacturing and purchasing.  
  • Supports Bank Reconciliation: Supports bank reconciliation, multiple bank accounts and user-defined adjustment types.  
  • Tracks and Traces Serial/Lot: Traces and tracks lots and serial nos. Provides users with details about historical inventory and lets users reassign serial and lot numbers, provide locations and relocate inventory quickly.  
read more...
  • Improve Communication: Communicate with suppliers by providing them access to the QAD Supplier Portal. Additionally, QAD Cloud EDI provides translation and communication services that work with QAD Cloud eCommerce. The result is end-to-end communication with trade partners. 
  • Increase Throughput: The system uses “Drum-Buffer-Rope” techniques to optimize the supply chain. Employees can receive automatic notifications when there are backorders or shortages that will affect the manufacturing process. 
  • Better Visibility: Better visibility allows you to be aware of demand changes and work quickly to accommodate them. The analytics dashboard provides the user with unified data from multiple sources and the product genealogy feature tracks products. Other features that provide better visibility include the CRM feature, which supplies customer service technicians with all customer information they could need. The financial management module allows the user to view key financial information. 
  • Maximize Productivity: QAD Warehousing reduces the need for additional labor and makes current warehouse employees more productive. The system uses consolidated picking to reduce traffic and enable multiple tasks within each trip in the warehouse. 
  • Make Strategic Business Decisions:  From analytics to budgeting, the system supplies users with the tools to make well-informed and data-driven business decisions. The user has instant access to this information from any mobile device, so you’re able to make business decisions anytime, anywhere.  
  • Governance, Risk and Compliance:  Ensure you are staying compliant with your financial reports concerning regulations such as Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) or J-SOX. 
read more...
  • Accounting: Integrates business operations to manage invoicing, pay bills, sales tax and more. Integrates with Avalara for end-to-end compliance. Leverage operational and financial information using KPI dashboards. Supports accounts payable and receivable, bank reconciliations, multi-company financial consolidation, tax management. Also generates financial statements and reconciles general ledgers.  
  • CRM and Sales: Supports robust sales tools and customer relationship management to streamline prospecting, managing vendor contracts, RMAs and sales. Print item labels and t/o forms, identify location details, inventory history, relocation, reassign serial and lot no., manage multi-locations in the warehouse and warehouse transfer orders.  
  • Reports: Generates reports which provide valid locations by item, quantities on hand by zone and location, expired inventory, location, lot and serial number, substitute availability, history by location, lot and serial numbers. Also provides usage and time-phased usage statistics and inventory status.  
  • KPI Dashboards: Dashboards support one-time delivery, scrap percentage, RMAs and returns, units produced by product, work order schedule and status, inventory availability and pending material availability.  
  • Warehouse Transfer Orders: Lets users create new and open lists of inventory. Release physical inventory by agent, create count tags and cycle count tags, enter count slip, tags and miscellaneous inventory count, post count slips and tags, purge posted count slips and tags and generate reports.  
  • Financial Statements: Provides all basic statements, and all statements are customizable. Generate ad-hoc statements, drill down into general ledgers and back to source transactions while allowing unlimited iterations. Supports export and print features.  
  • Fixed Assets: Supports multi-level asset serial tracking, book value tracking, location tracking, multiple depreciation methods, warranty and purchase tracking, multiple disposition options, full transaction history and ad hoc and scheduled maintenance orders.
read more...
  • Manufacturing: Track products throughout the production process, print labels, gain visibility into plans, schedules and supporting data. Lean manufacturing improves quality and eliminates waste. The Master Scheduling Workbench allows you to simulate changes to the schedule before you confirm changes to it.  
  • Supply Chain Management: You can plan, track and manage costs through the Distribution Requirements Planning feature. The QAD Supplier Portal allows you to share information about inventory, scheduling, purchase orders, shipments and more with your suppliers. QAD Warehousing handles complex warehouses and high volume picking. You can access pending acquisitions from your mobile device.  
  • Customer Management: The CRM feature provides a 360-degree view of your customer interactions and processes sales orders and invoices. The Customer Self Service feature provides the user with a web store-front that you can match to your own website’s branding. The configurator allows for mass production of customized products that may be delivered from any facility, no matter where the user initially did the configuration. Customer service and support run the entire services lifecycle, from managing service orders to providing all customer information that servicing personnel could need to perform their job. 
  • Financial Management: A general ledger, accounts receivable and payable are made available to you through the financial management feature. Other capabilities include multi-currency, cost management, credit management, budgeting and financial analysis. The system generates periodic or ad-hoc corporate and governmental reports, consolidates financial records and manages and tracks freight costs.  
  • Analytics: QAD BI displays your data at a single source, and users can access this information from any mobile device. You can create and run reports while managing your business processes with this feature.  
  • Integration: The software comes with robust ERP system integration solutions. QAD Cloud EDI streamlines communication between customers and suppliers, while QAD EDI eCommerce provides tighter integration with your trading partners. QAD Boomi AtomSphere can connect cloud applications to on-premise applications without requiring any additional hardware. QAD Q-Xtend automates data synchronization and eliminates both manual data entry and custom interfaces maintenance.  
read more...

Product Ranking

#55

among all
Manufacturing Software

#18

among all
Manufacturing Software

Find out who the leaders are

User Sentiment Summary

Great User Sentiment 235 reviews
Good User Sentiment 54 reviews
84%
of users recommend this product

xTuple has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 84% when considering 235 user reviews from 3 recognized software review sites.

74%
of users recommend this product

QAD ERP has a 'good' User Satisfaction Rating of 74% when considering 54 user reviews from 3 recognized software review sites.

2.9 (4)
3.4 (12)
4.21 (115)
n/a
4.2 (116)
3.9 (14)
n/a
3.7 (28)

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

User Friendly: The system is easy to use and intuitive, as noted by approximately 90% of users who mention the system’s usability.
Support: Support for the system is excellent, as reported by 100% of users who mention support.
Interface: The interface is intuitive and user-friendly, as recognized by 66% of the users who mention its user interface and ease of use.
Cost: Nearly 86% of users who mentioned cost reported that the tool is very cost-effective as customized installs can be done at only 1/3rd of the cost of similar tools.
Show more
Enhanced Visibility and Control: Gain real-time insights into production, inventory, and finances to make informed decisions and proactively address issues.
Streamlined Operations: Automate manual tasks, reduce errors, and improve process efficiency across various manufacturing functions.
Improved Collaboration: Facilitate better communication and data sharing between departments, breaking down silos and enhancing teamwork.
Scalability and Flexibility: Adapt to changing business needs and growth, accommodating new users, locations, and processes seamlessly.
Industry-Specific Features: Benefit from pre-built functionality and best practices tailored to specific manufacturing industries, such as automotive, food and beverage, and life sciences.
Show more
Reporting: The reporting feature has minimal reports, and users may want to write custom reports or purchase third party software, as noted by 100% of the users who mention the tool’s reporting capabilities.
Implementation: The physical implementation process misses the mark and can be difficult according to 50% of reviewers who mention implementation.
Show more
Complex Implementation: Requires significant upfront investment and technical expertise for setup and configuration.
High Customization Costs: Extensive customization can be expensive and time-consuming.
Steeper Learning Curve: User interface can be complex and require training for efficient use.
Limited Reporting Capabilities: Out-of-the-box reporting may not meet all needs, requiring additional development.
Potential Integration Challenges: Integrating with existing systems can be complex and require specialized skills.
Show more

xTuple is a useful and intuitive tool. Users like its sales, financial and inventory tracking features. The program’s features can be extended by a tech-savvy administrator with xTuple’s open-source tool. The support team is helpful and resolves bug fixes quickly. The reporting feature may be lacking as only basic reports are generated. Users either use third-party software or customize it to generate custom reports. It offers great value for its cost. Customizing the tool, according to business needs, is possible.

Show more

User reviews of QAD ERP reveal a love-hate relationship. Fans tout its industry-specific muscle and enhanced control, with one user gushing, "It's like SAP on steroids for automakers; we finally have real-time visibility into production flows." However, its complexity can be daunting. "Compared to Acumatica," admits another, "QAD has a steeper learning curve, but its customization blows it out of the water, especially for our intricate assembly lines." The customization aspect is a double-edged sword. "Implementing QAD was an Everest-sized task," laments one reviewer, "and ongoing tweaks can be pricey compared to something like NetSuite." In the end, user experiences suggest QAD shines for manufacturers craving a highly configurable and industry-specific platform, but be prepared to invest sweat and tears (and dollars) in implementation and training.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in Manufacturing Software

Acumatica
Aptean ERP
Cetec ERP
DELMIAworks
Dynamics 365 Business Central
Dynamics 365 SCM
Epicor Kinetic
JobBOSS²
Katana MRP
MIE Trak Pro
MRPEasy
NetSuite
Oracle Fusion Cloud
Plex Systems
Sage 100 Cloud
SAP S/4HANA Cloud
SYSPRO
SyteLine
Visibility ERP

Related Categories

Accounting Practice Management Software
Accounting Software
Accounting Software For Architects
Accounting Software For Consultants
Accounts Payable Software
Accounts Receivable Software
Additive Manufacturing Software
Aerospace Manufacturing Software
Apparel ERP Software
Apparel Manufacturing Software
Auto Dealer Accounting Software
Bank Accounting Software
Banking Software
Bill Of Materials Software
Bookkeeping Software
Budgeting And Forecasting Software
Budgeting Software
Business Management Software
CAE Software
Capacity Planning Software
Chemical Manufacturing Software
Contract Lifecycle Management Software
CPA Software
Discrete Manufacturing Software
Distribution Inventory Management Software
Distribution Software
Ecommerce Accounting Software
Electronics Manufacturing Software
ERP Software
Expense Report Software
Farm Accounting Software
Financial Management Systems
Financial Reporting Software
Food Distribution Software
Food Manufacturing Software
Food Safety Software
Food Traceability Software
Fund Accounting Software
General Ledger Software
Healthcare ERP Systems
Higher Education ERP Systems
Hotel Accounting Software
Insurance Accounting Software
Invoice Automation Software
Invoicing Software For Small Business
Lean Manufacturing Software
Legal Accounting Software
Manufacturing Accounting Systems
Manufacturing BI Software
Manufacturing Inventory Software
Media and Newspaper Accounting Software
Metal Fabrication Software
MRO Software
Nonprofit Accounting Software
OEE Software
Oil And Gas Accounting Software
Order Entry Software
Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Software
Production Management Software
Project Accounting Software
Property Management Accounting Software
Quality Management Software
Real Estate Accounting Software
Recurring Billing Software
Restaurant Accounting Software
Retail Accounting Software
Revenue Management Software
School Accounting Software
SPC Software
SRM Software
Subscription Management Software
Supply Chain Management Software
Supply Chain Planning Software
Time and Billing Software
Treasury Management Software
Trucking Accounting Software
Trust Accounting Software
Show more
Additive Manufacturing Software
Aerospace Manufacturing Software
Apparel ERP Software
Apparel Manufacturing Software
Bill Of Materials Software
Business Management Software
CAE Software
Capacity Planning Software
Chemical Manufacturing Software
Discrete Manufacturing Software
Electronics Manufacturing Software
ERP Software
Food Manufacturing Software
Food Safety Software
Healthcare ERP Systems
Higher Education ERP Systems
Lean Manufacturing Software
Manufacturing Accounting Systems
Manufacturing BI Software
Manufacturing Inventory Software
Metal Fabrication Software
MRO Software
OEE Software
Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Software
Production Management Software
Quality Management Software
SPC Software
Supply Chain Management Software
Show more

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

SelectHub Products Reporting and Analytics
Build Your Requirements
SelectHub Products Cost and Pricing Guide
Get Your Free Comparison Report
Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
    Table settings