ETAP vs ECi M1

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared ETAP vs ECi M1 based on data from our 400+ point analysis of Manufacturing Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

ECi M1 Software Tool

Product Basics

ETAP is a comprehensive software solution designed to manage and optimize manufacturing processes. It is particularly well-suited for industries that require detailed electrical power system analysis and management, such as manufacturing plants, due to its robust capabilities in modeling, simulation, and real-time monitoring. The software offers significant benefits, including enhanced operational efficiency, improved safety, and reduced downtime through predictive maintenance and fault analysis.

Popular features of ETAP include load flow analysis, short circuit analysis, arc flash analysis, and dynamic system simulation. These features enable users to design, operate, and automate their electrical power systems with precision. Users have praised ETAP for its user-friendly interface and the depth of its analytical tools, which often surpass those of similar products in the market.

Pricing for ETAP can vary widely based on the specific modules and features required, as well as the scale of deployment. It is typically offered on a subscription basis, with costs potentially ranging from a few thousand to several tens of thousands of dollars annually. For precise pricing tailored to individual needs, it is recommended to contact SelectHub for a detailed quote.

read more...
ECI M1 is a solution that obtains real-time process transparency for small and mid-sized companies. It cuts costs to save money and boosts productivity. Its top features include production management, inventory supervision, scheduling, shipping and a resource planner.

It reviews everything from order entries to shipping in real time. Gain in-depth insights on equipment downtime, capacity and inventory. Link orders and invoices to existing materials for full transparency.
read more...
$700 Annually, Quote-based
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$5,000 Monthly
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Improved Efficiency: ETAP streamlines manufacturing processes by automating routine tasks, reducing the time and effort required for manual operations.
  • Enhanced Accuracy: By minimizing human error through automated data entry and calculations, ETAP ensures higher precision in production planning and execution.
  • Cost Reduction: Optimizing resource allocation and minimizing waste, ETAP helps lower operational costs and improve profitability.
  • Real-Time Monitoring: ETAP provides live updates on production status, enabling managers to make informed decisions quickly and effectively.
  • Scalability: The software can easily adapt to the growing needs of a business, supporting expansion without significant additional investment.
  • Regulatory Compliance: ETAP assists in maintaining compliance with industry standards and regulations by ensuring accurate record-keeping and reporting.
  • Data-Driven Insights: Advanced analytics and reporting tools in ETAP offer valuable insights into production trends, helping to identify areas for improvement.
  • Enhanced Collaboration: By providing a centralized platform for information sharing, ETAP fosters better communication and collaboration among team members.
  • Predictive Maintenance: ETAP's predictive analytics can forecast equipment failures, allowing for proactive maintenance and reducing downtime.
  • Inventory Management: The software optimizes inventory levels, ensuring that materials are available when needed while avoiding overstocking.
  • Energy Efficiency: ETAP helps monitor and manage energy consumption, leading to more sustainable manufacturing practices and cost savings.
  • Customer Satisfaction: By improving production quality and reducing lead times, ETAP contributes to higher customer satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Flexibility: The software supports various manufacturing methodologies, including lean manufacturing and just-in-time production, allowing businesses to choose the best approach for their needs.
  • Risk Management: ETAP helps identify potential risks in the production process, enabling businesses to implement mitigation strategies proactively.
  • Resource Optimization: By efficiently managing labor, materials, and machinery, ETAP ensures optimal use of resources, enhancing overall productivity.
read more...
  • Increase On-time Deliveries: Utilize stock, machinery and other data to enhance productivity and team collaboration to boost on-time deliveries and increase customer satisfaction. 
  • Reduce Costs: Implement shipping analytics and merge them with global shippers to gain operational visibility and eliminate bottlenecks to save time and money. 
  • Obtain Workflow Centralization: Govern sales, warehouses, inventory, production and files on multiple sites with a centralized solution to monitor and supervise all activities. Gain in-depth business activity from any location to better manage and address issues. 
  • Boost Collaboration: Share job information with shop floor teams for increased communication and productivity by keeping everyone on the same page with real-time data. 
  • Reduce Machine Downtime: Automate scheduling to reduce idle machines, unnecessary overtime and missed deadlines while boosting production KPIs and client satisfaction rates. 
read more...
  • Load Flow Analysis: Provides detailed analysis of power flow in electrical networks, helping to optimize system performance.
  • Short Circuit Analysis: Calculates fault currents and helps in designing protective devices to ensure system safety.
  • Arc Flash Analysis: Assesses potential arc flash hazards and recommends safety measures to protect personnel.
  • Transient Stability Analysis: Evaluates the system's ability to remain stable under transient conditions, such as sudden load changes or faults.
  • Harmonic Analysis: Identifies and mitigates harmonic distortions in the electrical system to improve power quality.
  • Protective Device Coordination: Ensures that protective devices are properly coordinated to minimize system downtime during faults.
  • Motor Acceleration Analysis: Analyzes the impact of motor starting on the electrical network, ensuring reliable operation.
  • Reliability Assessment: Evaluates the reliability of the electrical system and identifies areas for improvement.
  • Load Shedding and Restoration: Automates load shedding and restoration processes to maintain system stability during emergencies.
  • Real-Time Monitoring: Provides real-time data on system performance, enabling proactive maintenance and quick response to issues.
  • Network Topology Processor: Automatically updates the network model based on real-time data, ensuring accurate analysis.
  • Geospatial Information System (GIS) Integration: Integrates with GIS to provide a visual representation of the electrical network, aiding in planning and analysis.
  • Data Exchange and Interoperability: Supports data exchange with other systems and software, facilitating seamless integration into existing workflows.
  • Customizable Reporting: Generates detailed, customizable reports to meet specific regulatory and operational requirements.
  • Scenario Analysis: Allows users to simulate different scenarios and assess their impact on the electrical system.
  • Energy Management System (EMS) Integration: Integrates with EMS to optimize energy usage and reduce operational costs.
  • Training and Simulation: Provides a platform for training personnel and simulating various operational scenarios to enhance preparedness.
  • Compliance Tracking: Helps ensure compliance with industry standards and regulations through automated tracking and reporting.
  • Advanced Visualization Tools: Offers advanced visualization tools to help users understand complex data and make informed decisions.
  • Modular Architecture: Features a modular architecture that allows users to add or remove functionalities based on their specific needs.
read more...
  • Production Management: Maintain job schedules and track labor to control fees. 
  • Inventory Management: Merge all business data in real time and track all stock information across business functions. 
  • Scheduling: Automate schedules to meet maximum performance for discrete and other production methods. 
  • Shipping Management: Automate and simplify shipping tasks with in-depth analytical and Order Snapshot tools to monitor on-time deliveries and adjust accordingly. 
  • Manufacturing Resource Planner (MRP): Manage and arrange multiple facilities to keep up with ever-changing supply and demand. 
  • Quality Management: Perform automatic, customized requirements for product inspections and quality analyses. Verify improvement areas to keep bottom lines and reputations intact. 
  • General Ledger: Unite all financial data, including accounts payable and receivable, payroll, fixed assets register and credit card processing into one centralized system. 
  • Design Studio: Add new fields, change input documents, shift objects and create recent reports. Change search grids to exhibit data in several ways. 
  • Product Configurator: Craft and adjust anything from single-level BOMs to intricate products and parts. 
  • Shop Floor Entry: Gain accurate job fees, prioritizations, real-time job statuses and collected payroll hours. 
read more...

Product Ranking

#57

among all
Manufacturing Software

#126

among all
Manufacturing Software

Find out who the leaders are

User Sentiment Summary

Excellent User Sentiment 81 reviews
we're gathering data
91%
of users recommend this product

ETAP has a 'excellent' User Satisfaction Rating of 91% when considering 81 user reviews from 1 recognized software review sites.

we're gathering data
4.54 (81)
n/a

Awards

ETAP stands above the rest by achieving an ‘Excellent’ rating as a User Favorite.

User Favorite Award

we're gathering data

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

Trusted Results: ETAP provides reliable and accurate data and calculations, giving users confidence in their system analysis.
User-Friendly Interface: The software features a graphical user interface that simplifies complex modeling tasks, making it accessible to both new and experienced users.
Comprehensive Analysis: ETAP offers a wide array of tools and modules for performing various power system studies, enabling users to analyze and optimize their systems effectively.
Customizable Reporting: Users can tailor reports to their specific needs, including detailed analysis or concise summaries, facilitating clear communication and decision-making.
Responsive Support: ETAP provides reliable technical support and resources, ensuring users have assistance when encountering challenges or requiring guidance.
Show more
Comprehensive Feature Set: ECi M1 offers a wide array of functions, covering production planning, inventory control, and financial management, making it a comprehensive solution for small to medium-sized manufacturers.
Flexible and Customizable: The software's adaptability to different manufacturing processes is a key advantage, allowing businesses to tailor the system to their specific needs.
Improved Operational Efficiency: Many users report that once ECi M1 is fully implemented, it significantly streamlines operations, leading to increased productivity and reduced manual processes.
Show more
Cost: Users have reported that the software requires the purchase of numerous modules. This can be frustrating for users as they may start a project only to realize they need an additional module for a key feature.
Complexity: The software is powerful and feature-rich, which can make it challenging to learn and require extensive training to master. Users have mentioned that getting reacquainted with the software after a period of not using it can be time-consuming.
Show more
Steep Learning Curve: ECi M1 has a steep learning curve, meaning it can be challenging and time-consuming for users to get up to speed with the software's functionality.
Customer Support Responsiveness: Some users have reported issues with the responsiveness of ECi M1's customer support, which could be problematic when facing urgent technical difficulties or needing assistance.
Complex Initial Setup: The initial setup of ECi M1 can be complex and time-consuming, requiring significant effort and potentially specialized expertise to configure the system correctly.
Limited Batch Manufacturing Support: ECi M1 is not ideal for batch manufacturing, which could be a drawback for businesses that heavily rely on this production method.
Lack of Low-Code Customizations: Unlike some competing ERP systems, ECi M1 does not offer low-code customization options, making it potentially less flexible for businesses with unique requirements not addressed by the software's standard features.
Show more

Is ETAP software the easiest tap into the world of electrical power system design and analysis? User reviews from the last year suggest that it might just be! ETAP consistently receives high praise for its user-friendly interface and robust functionality. Users highlight the intuitive one-line diagram interface, which simplifies the process of creating and analyzing complex power systems, as a key strength that sets it apart from competitors. For instance, one user, who previously used SKM Power Tools, found ETAP to be far easier to use and understand. However, some users express frustration with the pricing model, specifically the need to purchase numerous modules to access specific features. Despite this drawback, ETAP is widely regarded as a powerful and essential tool for power system engineers. ETAP's focus on providing detailed reports and analysis tools is another major plus. Users appreciate the software's ability to generate comprehensive reports, including star graphs that are visually appealing and easy to interpret. This feature is particularly valuable for presenting findings to stakeholders and justifying design decisions. The availability of macros for automating repetitive tasks further enhances efficiency and productivity, making it ideal for large-scale projects. Overall, ETAP emerges as the go-to choice for professionals involved in the design, analysis, and operation of electrical power systems. Its user-friendly interface, powerful features, and comprehensive reporting capabilities make it an invaluable asset for both seasoned engineers and those new to the field. While the pricing structure may pose a challenge for some, the software's exceptional value proposition and industry-leading reputation solidify its position as a top contender in the market.

Show more

Is ECi M1 manufacturing a monumental success in the world of ERP software? Recent user reviews suggest a somewhat nuanced picture. While ECi M1 garners praise for its robust functionality, particularly in inventory management, production scheduling, and financial reporting, some users find the initial learning curve to be a bit steep. Many users, especially those already familiar with manufacturing software, appreciate the depth of features, citing the comprehensive inventory tracking and detailed production planning capabilities as major wins for streamlining operations and reducing costly errors. However, the software's complexity can be daunting for some, leading to initial setup challenges and a longer onboarding period. This robust functionality also appears to be a key differentiator for ECi M1. Unlike more general-purpose ERP solutions, ECi M1 is purpose-built for the intricacies of manufacturing, which resonates with users who find generic ERP systems to be a poor fit. The software's ability to integrate with other software is another often-cited advantage, enabling businesses to create a more unified technology ecosystem. That said, the responsiveness of customer support has been an occasional source of frustration for some users, who have reported delays in getting issues resolved. Overall, ECi M1 appears to be best suited for small to medium-sized manufacturers who need a powerful, specialized solution and are willing to invest the time to overcome the initial learning curve.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in Manufacturing Software


Acumatica

Aptean ERP

Cetec ERP

DELMIAworks

Dynamics 365 Business Central

Dynamics 365 SCM

Epicor Kinetic

JobBOSS²

Katana MRP

MIE Trak Pro

MRPEasy

NetSuite

Oracle Fusion Cloud

Plex Systems

Sage 100 Cloud

SAP S/4HANA Cloud

SYSPRO

SyteLine

Visibility ERP

Related Categories

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
Table settings