Humanity vs Deputy

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared Humanity vs Deputy based on data from our 400+ point analysis of Employee Scheduling Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Product Basics

Humanity is an end-to-end platform for all your scheduling needs. It helps you create schedules in minutes and offers AI-powered suggestions to avoid overscheduling and staffing errors while ensuring proper coverage and compliance with labor regulations.

The platform's intelligent algorithms analyze employee availability, skill sets and workload to generate optimal schedules that align with forecasted demand. You can define custom rules to address specific requirements and reduce manual effort.

Humanity serves as a central repository for scheduling data. It maintains a detailed employee database, historical records and audit logs, helping you manage workforce information and ensure accountability. A demand forecasting module helps predict future staffing needs based on seasonal demand and optimize workforce allocation. 

Additionally, it includes robust features to address compliance and employee well-being. The platform automatically creates breaks based on predefined state rules, ensuring adequate meal breaks and compliance with labor regulations. Employees also get personal portals to view schedules, swap shifts, chat with managers and colleagues, and send time off requests.

The mobile app empowers managers and employees to create schedules, communicate effectively, and track time and attendance from anywhere. Its geofencing feature helps prevent malpractices like time theft, buddy punching and clocking in from outside the work location. 

Pros
  • User-friendly interface
  • Mobile app
  • Customization and flexibility
  • Responsive customer support
Cons
  • Slow performance
  • Integration challenges
  • Bugs and UI issues
read more...

Deputy is a one-stop shop for hiring, training, scheduling, paying and managing time sheets of frontline and hourly workers. It offers an intuitive interface and various features to help manage employees, streamline scheduling operations and simplify internal communications.

You can easily create, edit and manage schedules while ensuring optimal staffing levels. The platform's drag-and-drop functionality allows quick adjustments to accommodate changes in staffing or workload. Time clock features enable employees to clock in and out accurately, minimizing the risk of time theft and simplifying payroll processing.

Also, Deputy provides a comprehensive suite of HR tools, including features for managing time off. Employees can easily request and track vacation, sick leave and other absences. A built-in messaging portal facilitates internal communication and records interactions to promote accountability.

You can also post job openings on popular online channels and create a branded portal to accept applications. The system lets you design a new hire’s onboarding workflow with embedded training materials and tips. Additionally, customizable automation helps businesses comply with fair workweek regulations, break rules, maximum work hours, consecutive workdays and other labor regulations.

One of the platform’s standout features is its pre-built integrations and extensibility with other third-party solutions. The vendor lets you add extra features such as payroll processing, business intelligence, demand forecasting, point of sale system and more.


read more...
$3/User, Monthly
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$2.50/User, Monthly, Freemium
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Streamline Employee Management: Humanity offers a robust employee management toolkit with a 100 analyst rating, according to our data. You can manage employee certificates, track expiration dates and offer them unique self-service portals. Employees can handle multiple job positions from a centralized portal and submit feedback on stress levels and fatigue. The platform categorizes employee segments and helps you compare labor costs with demand forecasts for effective budgeting.
  • Manage Schedules From Anywhere: The platform provides one of the most robust scheduling mobile apps, earning a perfect 100 rating from our analysts. It includes toolkits for ad-hoc scheduling, team communications and custom notifications. It supports geofencing to track employee locations and offers a time clock to log staff work hours in a timesheet. You can also create schedules offline and define rules to automatically publish them at the right time.
  • Create Schedules Effectively: Another strong suite is the scheduling toolkit, which got a 93 rating from our analysts. You can use drag-and-drop tools and templates to create shifts manually or define rules for the native AI to do it automatically. Copy schedules with or without employees and apply them across multiple departments and locations. Employees can specify their skills, and the platform creates skill-based schedules. You can control each shift’s visibility based on user roles and set permission levels for shift swap and trading approval workflows.
read more...
  • Create The Perfect Software Stack: Deputy won the SelectHub award for having the best integrations and extensibility options among employee scheduling tools, with 96 analyst score. It offers pre-built integrations with popular accounting solutions, online calendars, HRMS software, HCM tools and iPaaS platforms. You can easily import or export data and access the API to design custom integrations with external solutions.
  • Work From Anywhere: The platform offers one of the most robust scheduling mobile apps that lets you manage operations from any remote location. With a perfect 100 analyst rating, it supports offline scheduling, chat options, team news sharing, mobile time clocks, GPS tracking and customizable push notifications.
  • Streamline Scheduling: Another top-rated module is its scheduling toolkit, which has a 93 rating from our analysts. You get customizable templates and drag-and-drop tools to design schedules in minutes. The built-in AI sends conflict alerts for unavailable employees and compliance issues, ensuring schedules are accurate and efficient. The platform automatically updates employee calendars upon publishing a schedule and offers them the option of first refusal, shift swapping and bidding via their unique portals.
  • Manage Timesheets Efficiently: It offers a robust time and attendance management module that got a 92 rating from our analysts. Employees can track work hours via the mobile app, and the platform automatically prevents early clock-ins, sends break reminders, tracks overtime and maintains timesheets. It also automatically clocks out employees and prevents overtime based on your business’s budget and compliance regulations.
read more...
  • Employee Scheduling: Create conflict-free schedules using intuitive drag-and-drop schedule makers. Update schedules in real time while receiving overstaffing or understaffing notifications on a daily or weekly basis. Assign, remove and swap shifts easily based on staff availability, skills and preferences.
  • Time Clock: Track employee attendance and hours via the mobile app and maintain accurate timesheets. Mandate employees to click pictures while clocking in or out to avoid malpractices like buddy punching. Set punctuality rules to curb absenteeism and accidental absences.
  • Leave Management: Employees can manage their schedules and work-life balance using unique portals. Customize leave types to suit company needs while allowing partial day leaves. Set vacation and PTO rules to avoid understaffing.
  • Integrations: Integrate with popular third-party ERP, HCM, payroll and HR modules to streamline business operations. Export payroll to over 30 modules like Ceridian, ADP, Ultimate Software and Paycheck. Integrate with external HR modules like BambooHR.
  • Forecast: Use external performance indicators to predict future staffing needs and design efficient employee schedules. Customize schedules based on business priorities and capacity to tackle both under-staffing and over-staffing challenges.
  • Geofencing: Enable geofencing to ensure employees check in and out from the correct locations. Activate the GPS facility to track field staff location accurately.
read more...
  • Scheduling: Create, manage and optimize schedules with AI. Use drag-and-drop scheduling tools while considering availability, skills and preferences to create partial, pre-assigned or open shifts.
  • Time Tracking: Turn staff phones into a time tracking solution using the mobile app or connect the platform to a POS system to allow employees to punch in and out of work. The platform sends alerts for break hours, overtime and budgetary conflicts. It also offers geofencing to help avoid time theft and buddy punching.
  • Mobile App: Managers can access their profiles from anywhere, create schedules, approve time off requests, communicate with team members and track task progress. Employees can view schedules, request PTO, chat with colleagues, swap shifts and bid on open shifts.
  • Demand Forecasting: Access your business’s historical sales data and seasonal trends on a centralized dashboard to make informed staffing decisions. Define business logic and benchmarks with demand-based rules to ensure minimum coverage while considering your budget. You can pull real-time wage-to-sales data on the mobile app to make scheduling adjustments on the go.
  • Shift Pulse: Send feedback forms and questionnaires to employees after every shift. Minimize staff fatigue by automating schedule assignments based on worked hours and overtime. Employees can express their work satisfaction using a staff sentiment bar and tracker.
  • Compliance Tools: Deputy helps comply with fair workweek regulations by providing tools to manage overtime, minimum rest periods and other labor laws. It also assists with reporting, managing employee records and ensuring adherence to minimum wage laws.
  • Leave Management: Employees can submit time-off requests directly through the platform, and managers can review and approve or deny them. You can also track leave balances and generate leave reports.
  • Document Management: The platform offers a centralized repository for storing and organizing employee documents, such as contracts, performance reviews and training certificates. Its search and filtering capabilities make it easy to find specific documents when needed.
  • Hiring: Post openings on online job forums and track their traction from within the software interface. You can track applicants, schedule interviews, send questions and receive applicant feedback.
  • Training and Onboarding: Design branded onboarding workflows for trainees and manage employee training programs by tracking attendance, assigning tasks and monitoring progress.
read more...

Product Ranking

#1

among all
Employee Scheduling Software

#8

among all
Employee Scheduling Software

Find out who the leaders are

Analyst Rating Summary

86
89
52
91
100
85
91
78
Show More Show More
Employee Management
Mobile Capabilities
Schedule Management
Leave and Absence Management
Time and Attendance Management
Mobile Capabilities
Integrations and Extensibility
Schedule Management
Time and Attendance Management
Collaboration

Analyst Ratings for Functional Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

Humanity
Deputy
+ Add Product + Add Product
Collaboration Employee Management Leave And Absence Management Mobile Capabilities Platform Capabilities Reporting And Analytics Schedule Management Security And Compliance Shift Management Time And Attendance Management 52 100 91 100 75 83 96 83 79 85 91 85 78 100 88 64 95 76 89 94 0 25 50 75 100
50%
0%
50%
88%
0%
12%
100%
0%
0%
83%
0%
17%
88%
0%
12%
75%
0%
25%
100%
0%
0%
100%
0%
0%
78%
0%
22%
89%
0%
11%
83%
0%
17%
67%
0%
33%
95%
0%
5%
95%
0%
5%
78%
0%
22%
78%
0%
22%
79%
0%
21%
89%
0%
11%
84%
0%
16%
95%
0%
5%

Analyst Ratings for Technical Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

70%
0%
30%
90%
0%
10%

User Sentiment Summary

Great User Sentiment 1401 reviews
Excellent User Sentiment 1504 reviews
86%
of users recommend this product

Humanity has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 86% when considering 1401 user reviews from 5 recognized software review sites.

90%
of users recommend this product

Deputy has a 'excellent' User Satisfaction Rating of 90% when considering 1504 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.

4.3 (14)
4.3 (15)
4.3 (1032)
4.7 (307)
4.3 (296)
4.6 (720)
4.8 (51)
n/a
4.2 (8)
4.2 (462)

Awards

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated Humanity and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Employee Management and Mobile Capabilities.

Employee Management Award
Mobile Capabilities Award

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated Deputy and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Mobile Capabilities and Integrations and Extensibility. Deputy stands above the rest by achieving an ‘Excellent’ rating as a User Favorite.

User Favorite Award
Mobile Capabilities Award
Integrations and Extensibility Award

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

User-Friendly Interface: The interface is easy for both managers and employees to navigate. Despite some initial learning curves, users appreciate its simplicity, which can eliminate the need for extensive tutorials or training.
Robust Mobile App: It provides quick and convenient access to scheduling and clocking functionalities. Despite occasional issues like freezing, the app streamlines clock-in/out processes and enables on-the-go schedule management.
Customization and Flexibility: The platform offers customizable views and filters, enabling users to tailor schedules to their specific needs. Additionally, features like Open Shifts empower employees to pick up available shifts based on their preferences, enhancing scheduling flexibility.
Responsive Customer Support: Humanity stands out for its responsiveness, and users appreciate the promptness of live chat support and quick resolution times.
Show more
User-Friendly Interface: Users appreciate the intuitive design, which makes it accessible for both managers and employees and easy to adopt with minimal training.
Robust Remote Workability: The mobile app is highly praised for allowing employees to clock in/out, manage shifts and receive notifications, making it convenient for on-the-go use.
Greater Flexibility and Accessibility: Deputy offers flexible shift management, allowing employees to swap or pick up shifts and work across multiple locations. Cloud-based hosting ensures access from anywhere with an internet connection.
Employee Empowerment: The software gives employees more control over their schedules, fostering a sense of ownership and responsibility for time management.
Streamline Scheduling: Deputy effectively manages scheduling, time tracking and attendance, reducing errors and improving overall efficiency. Reviews highlight valuable features like preventing early clock-ins and integrating with payroll systems.
Show more
Slow Performance and Loading Times: Humanity can take a long time to load larger schedules or perform certain tasks. This can hinder navigation between different sections.
Integration Challenges: Many users faced issues while connecting the platform with third-party ERP and HCM solutions like Zendesk and ADP Workforce Now.
Bugs and UI Issues: Users experienced bugs within the user interface, ranging from occasional instability to unexpected template malfunctions.
Changes in User Experience and Functionality: Some users mentioned that certain features they found useful were removed or altered, causing workflow disruptions and increasing complexity in using the software.
Show more
Support and Customer Service Issues: Several users reported poor customer service experiences, especially when dealing with technical support or canceling the service. The vendor primarily offers support via email, which some users found inadequate.
Performance and Speed: Some users experienced lag when accepting shifts or clocking in and out, causing delays and frustration.
Challenges With Multi-Location Tracking: For organizations with employees across multiple locations or states, keeping track of everyone’s whereabouts could be challenging as the platform doesn’t support multiple time zones across geographies.
Syncing Issues: Users noted that the inability to sync with external calendars (like Google or Apple Calendar) was a significant drawback.
Show more

Humanity's intuitive interface, coupled with guided onboarding and data migration assistance, makes it easy for organizations to get started with scheduling. The simple drag-and-drop tools and embedded training tips help you start scheduling within minutes.Its compliance management toolkit is a standout feature, ensuring adherence to labor laws, internal policies, regulations and CBAs. It provides a set of default rules and offers you the freedom to write custom ones. The platform also sends conflict alerts and maintains historical records and audit logs, contributing to a secure and compliant environment.Humanity's mobile app is another significant advantage. It offers managers the same functionality as the desktop version, enabling them to create schedules, work offline and set up automation. Employees can view schedules, receive shift reminders, track work hours and even pick up open shifts with a single tap. The app's compatibility with the Apple Watch provides added convenience for managing schedules on the go.It’s an end-to-end platform catering to the needs of various stakeholders in frontline worker scheduling. Chief financial officers can track budgets and control labor costs, HR offices can ensure compliance and enhance employee experiences, frontline managers can manage schedules and coverage, and employees can have greater control over their work hours.While Humanity is well-suited for midsized companies, it isn’t ideal for large organizations. Users have reported slow performance and loading times, particularly when dealing with extensive schedules or performing complex tasks. Integration challenges with third-party ERP and HCM solutions can also be a concern. Additionally, users have encountered bugs and UI issues, ranging from instability to unexpected template malfunctions.Overall, Humanity is a great tool for managing employee schedules. It's easy to use and can help you improve your business's efficiency. However, it's important to be aware of the potential drawbacks before making a decision.

Show more

Deputy is a valuable asset for businesses looking to streamline their scheduling operations and enhance employee productivity. During my research, I found it to be a highly effective and centralized tool for hiring, training and scheduling employees. Users consistently praise its performance, with many giving it a 4.5-star rating.One of Deputy's standout features is its AI-powered automation, which can significantly improve scheduling and shift break compliance. However, it may require some initial setup and learning to function optimally. The touchless facial recognition clock-in feature is particularly valuable in today's post-pandemic world.I appreciate Deputy's commitment to employee empowerment. Its accountability measures, such as GPS tracking and facial recognition, effectively prevent time theft without compromising employee autonomy. The Shift Pulse feature is another valuable tool that fosters open communication between employees and management.While Deputy is a powerful solution, it's not without its flaws. I encountered bugs and glitches that occasionally disrupted the user experience. Slow performance, particularly for mobile app users and non-desk staff, can be frustrating. Additionally, GPS challenges can be problematic for businesses with multiple locations as the platform doesn’t support multiple time zones.The HR functionality is also limited, but I believe it has the potential to expand over time. Adding more languages to the interface would also make it more inclusive. Overall, I recommend Deputy to small to mid-sized organizations seeking a reliable and feature-rich scheduling solution that also offers basic HR functionalities.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in Employee Scheduling Software


7shifts

Deputy

Findmyshift

Homebase

OpenSimSim

Planday

Quinyx

ScheduleFlex

Shiftbase

Shiftboard

Sling

TimeForge

When I Work

WhenToWork

ZoomShift

Related Categories

Head-to-Head Comparison

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
Table settings