Procore vs CMiC

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared Procore vs CMiC based on data from our 400+ point analysis of Construction Management Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Product Basics

Designed for projects of all sizes, Procore aims to streamline communication, track finances and resources and handle projects from planning to delivery. Real-time data accessibility gives users actionable insights from a centralized dashboard. Users can leverage hundreds of integrations to boost efficiency.

It allows construction firms, contractors, architects and engineers to share data in the field, edit designs and provide up-to-date reports of a project’s life cycle. Manage multiple construction projects efficiently. Businesses can create and manage construction project schedules and filter information according to summary tasks and resources. Its product portfolio supports project management, quality and safety measures, construction finances and field productivity.

Pros
  • Centralized data & communication
  • Easy mobile access & field updates
  • Improved collaboration & transparency
  • Streamlined workflows & approvals
  • Robust reporting & analytics tools
Cons
  • Steeper learning curve & complexity
  • Higher cost compared to some options
  • Limited customization for specific needs
  • Potential for data silos & redundancy
  • Integration challenges with other software
read more...
CMiC is an end-to-end solution for both large and small projects.

With seamless integrations, it automates tasks, offers on-premise and cloud deployment, and addresses aspects like budgeting, forecasting, change orders, bidding, procurement, document management and business intelligence.

It facilitates resource planning with dynamic timelines, ensuring updated and accurate information to keep projects on schedule and within budget.

To learn more about CMiC, visit their company profile.
read more...
$375 Monthly
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$100/User, Monthly
Free Trial is unavailable →
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
we're gathering data
ApexInvest
BigConstruction
BradfordConstruction
DiMarcoConstructors
PennCo
Sussex
WeisBuilders

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Increase Project Efficiency: Automate time-intensive documentation processes, provide simple access for project managers and focus on collaboration to drive a smoothly running construction site. 
  • Mitigate Risks: Increase data visibility to give project managers a bird’s-eye view of potential problems before they arise. Decrease project slowdown by tackling issues proactively. 
  • Cloud Access and Backup: Access important documents using smart devices from anywhere. Store data safely using the cloud platform.
  • Enhance Collaboration: Bring teams together with a collaborative, online environment. Allow authorized users to edit and annotate designs and provide feedback to co-workers on any changes before they go into effect. 
  • Valuable Insights From Data: Draw data from across the platform and create simple visualizations and reports to give users a better view of how the business works. 
  • Customizable and Flexible: Connect preferred construction apps while working with customizable workflows. Give teams the power to work in a comfortable and efficient environment. 
read more...
  • Gain Project Visibility & Control: Unify project information in a single platform for seamless collaboration. Generate tailored reports and dashboards to track key performance indicators (KPIs). 
  • Enhance Financial Management: Improve overall cash flow and financial stability. According to a case study published on the vendor’s website, BIG Construction LLC reduced processing time for client invoices and financial cost bookings by 50-75%. 
  • Boost Productivity & Efficiency: Automate routine processes like managing RFIs, routing documents and tracking assets to free up staff time for more strategic tasks. According to a case study published on the vendor’s website, Wasatch Taylormade Builders LLC reduced RFI handling time by 50%. 
  • Elevate Risk Management: Improve safety performance through incident reporting and tracking. Identify and mitigate potential risks to minimize delays and costs. 
  • Achieve Scalability & Flexibility: Store data on the cloud to receive real-time updates without system slow-down while improving document security (with the PaaS option). Add more users or resources to the platform as needed. 
read more...
  • Contract Management: View the status of purchase orders and contracts. Track and distribute change orders, payment documents and contract documents. 
  • Project Management: Automatically send overdue reminders via email to clients to help manage RFIs. Attach photos, plans, specs and PDFs to RFIs. Allow workers to log project time off-site using the web or mobile app. Sort activities by day, week or month. Filter project programs by resources or summary tasks. 
  • Time and Material Tickets: Generate change requests from T&M tickets to secure payments for performed work. Collect e-signatures to avoid payment disputes. 
  • Contact Directory and Permissions: Export contacts in CSV format. Grant role-based permissions to access data at individual, company or project levels. 
  • Quality and Safety Measures: Mitigate risks using incident tools. Understand the root cause of problems by identifying trends and combing through data. Identify unsafe patterns on job sites by accessing near-miss and injury records. 
  • Storage Capabilities: Gain unlimited storage space by purchasing an annual access agreement. 
  • Mobile Interface: Access project documents off-site. 
  • Drawing Management: Allow collaborators to upload drawings by granting issuance permissions. Create 2D and 3D models or designs. 
  • Data Security: Store data securely with AES-256-bit encryption. Conduct backups, track users and allow teams to view, edit and upload electronic documents. 
  • BIM: Access BIM data from the field with the ability to display 2D and 3D models on mobile devices. Publish models to enhance team collaboration. Compare site conditions to avoid costly errors. 
  • Bid Management: Track and manage bid invitations while increasing visibility with a single, organized repository. Compare bids by cost codes, bidding histories and location of bidders. 
read more...
  • Bidding: Compare multiple bids side by side using bid leveling functionality. Automatically send invitations to bid to potential vendors. Enable bidders to download and view project documents with planroom management capabilities. 
  • Customer Relationship Management: Create sales opportunities and view crucial information such as linked contacts and tasks. Automatically perform duplication checks when creating new contacts to maintain data accuracy. 
  • Document Management: Securely store and manage all project-related documents, including drawings, specifications, submittals and RFIs, in a centralized database. 
    • Drawings: Automatically extract metadata such as titles, sheet numbers and trades. Compare drawing sheets and perform overlays for accurate revisions and insights. 
    • Specifications: Upload, review and manage specifications with ease using the web-based tool. Manage submittals seamlessly based on the provided specifications. 
    • Submittals: Ensure thorough submittal assessments with stakeholder-driven workflows. 
    • RFIs: Expedite information gathering by providing teams with instant access to relevant documents. 
  • Accounting: Manage finances for multiple companies and currencies. 
    • Accounts Payable: Automate invoice processing and payment approvals. Generate detailed reports on vendor activity and spending. 
    • Accounts Receivable: Manage customer invoicing, payment collection and credit limits. Reconcile client payments and apply them to the corresponding invoices for accurate AR records. 
    • General Ledger: Generate financial statements, perform cash flow analyses and produce custom reports with just a few clicks. Maintain a complete audit trail of financial activities to ensure regulatory compliance. 
    • Cost Management: Track labor, material and equipment costs using job costing tools. Issue subcontracts directly from the system. 
    • Financial Management: Identify over/underbilled jobs with WIP reports. Create and manage project budgets, comparing actual costs against budgeted amounts. 
  • Human Resources and Payroll: Simplify workforce management, empower team members and gain valuable insights. 
    • Workforce Management: Manage the entire recruitment process, from attracting candidates to onboarding new hires. Administer and manage employee compensation and benefits plans. 
    • Employee Self-Service: Enable employees to access and download pay stubs and W2s electronically. Allow staff to access information about their benefits plans, such as health, dental and vision insurance. 
    • Payroll: Process payroll accurately and timely, including deductions and taxes. Support various pay frequencies, such as weekly, bi-weekly and monthly. Pay employees with direct deposit. 
    • Crew Time: Encourage employees to track work hours and submit timesheets directly from mobile devices. Monitor and manage employee overtime to ensure compliance with labor laws. 
  • Inventory Management: Set low-stock alerts to prevent stockouts and delays in project execution. 
    • Inventory Tracking: Capture and create lot and serial numbers to track inventory levels in real time. 
    • Replenishment: Assemble kits of commonly used materials for faster and easier issuance. Determine order quantities, reorder points and forecast models to calculate replenishment. 
    • Inventory Valuation: Evaluate inventory using standard, average, specific (actual) and first-in-first-out (FIFO) costing methods. 
  • Mobile Capabilities: Access critical information and project-related materials from anywhere, at any time. 
  • Project Management: Set realistic timelines and dependencies to ensure on-time project completion. Produce change orders from RFIs. Manage subcontractor relationships efficiently. Conduct inspections and track corrective actions. 
  • Reporting & Dashboards: Create personalized dashboards to track key project metrics. Compare project performance against industry benchmarks. 

read more...

Product Ranking

#1

among all
Construction Management Software

#22

among all
Construction Management Software

Find out who the leaders are

Analyst Rating Summary

88
91
100
89
73
100
94
98
Show More Show More
Bonus Management
Mobile Capabilities
Platform Capabilities
Dashboard and Reporting
Platform and security capabilities
Budgeting and Forecasting
Platform Capabilities
Dashboard and Reporting
Reporting and Dashboards
Rewards and Recognition

Analyst Ratings for Functional Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

Procore
CMiC
+ Add Product + Add Product
Bonus Management Budgeting And Forecasting Dashboard And Reporting Mobile Capabilities Mobile Capabilities Platform And Security Capabilities Platform Capabilities Reporting And Dashboards Rewards And Recognition Salary Management 100 73 94 100 94 97 86 89 90 89 100 98 88 80 100 98 93 84 0 25 50 75 100
100%
0%
0%
90%
0%
10%
60%
0%
40%
100%
0%
0%
89%
0%
11%
100%
0%
0%
100%
0%
0%
67%
0%
33%
100%
0%
0%
83%
0%
17%
100%
0%
0%
80%
0%
20%
100%
0%
0%
100%
0%
0%
88%
0%
12%
100%
0%
0%
80%
0%
20%
95%
0%
5%
80%
20%
0%
70%
0%
30%

Analyst Ratings for Technical Requirements Customize This Data Customize This Data

38%
0%
62%
88%
0%
12%

User Sentiment Summary

Great User Sentiment 6694 reviews
Good User Sentiment 477 reviews
89%
of users recommend this product

Procore has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 89% when considering 6694 user reviews from 5 recognized software review sites.

78%
of users recommend this product

CMiC has a 'good' User Satisfaction Rating of 78% when considering 477 user reviews from 5 recognized software review sites.

4.3 (17)
4.1 (7)
4.4 (794)
3.2 (16)
4.5 (2396)
4.14 (168)
4.5 (2534)
4.2 (164)
4.3 (953)
3.3 (122)

Awards

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated Procore and concluded it earns best-in-class honors for Bonus Management.

Bonus Management Award

SelectHub research analysts have evaluated CMiC and concluded it deserves the award for the Best Overall Construction Management Software available today and earns best-in-class honors for Budgeting and Forecasting, Platform Capabilities and Rewards and Recognition.

Analysts' Pick Award
Budgeting and Forecasting Award
Platform Capabilities Award
Rewards and Recognition Award

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

Functionality: All users that mentioned overall functionality liked its ability to perform different tasks such as invoicing, reporting, scheduling, submittals, RFIs and more, all in one tool.
Collaboration: All reviewers who referred to collaboration liked its ability to collaborate in real time with stakeholders and help teams bridge communication gaps while staying updated on current plans.
Cloud Based: All users who mentioned its cloud-based deployment liked that teams could easily access the tool from different geographical locations.
Tracking: All users that talked about tracking liked that they could keep track of individual employee production, employee timesheets and more.
Show more
Customization: Nearly 79% of users who talk about customization mention that the software is flexible and can be customized to meet unique business requirements.
Overall Functionality: Approximately 80% of users who refer to the overall functionality of the software recommend it to get the job done.
Data Management: Efficient data management and analysis is a big advantage of the product, as noted by about 64% of users who mention the feature.
Reports: CMiC helps users track, analyze and course-correct various aspects of project management with in-depth and insightful reports - a feature lauded by more than 63% of users who talk about the reporting feature.
Project Management: 100% of the users who talk about the project management module concur that it has made their operations more efficient.
Show more
Learning Curve: Due to its rich features, the system can be difficult to navigate and understand without proper training, as observed by 92% of users who specified the learning curve.
Performance: Almost all users who mentioned performance said that it takes time for the software to respond.
Updates: Around 85% of reviewers who specified updates said that frequent updates make keeping up with features challenging.
Show more
User Interface: Approximately 82% of users who mention the user interface note that the system is complicated and hard to navigate.
User-Friendliness: More than 84% of users who talk about user-friendliness as an important factor mention that the software is not easy to use.
Setup and Training: Nearly 100% of users who refer to setup and implementation note that training and onboarding support is lacking, making it difficult to adopt the software.
Glitches: Slow processing and frequent lags are detrimental to its usage, as pointed out by 100% of users who talk about issues and glitches.
Show more

Procore's user reviews paint a picture of a powerful construction management software with strengths in centralizing data, improving communication, and streamlining workflows. Users praise its mobile accessibility, robust reporting tools, and collaborative features, citing improved project visibility and reduced paperwork as key benefits. However, some reviewers mention a steeper learning curve compared to simpler options and a higher cost point. One recurring strength is Procore's ability to consolidate information and communication. Users appreciate having a central platform for documents, drawings, discussions, and updates, eliminating the need for multiple tools and email threads. This fosters transparency and reduces miscommunication, as exemplified by a reviewer who mentioned avoiding costly delays due to improved information flow. Another frequently lauded aspect is Procore's mobile app, enabling field teams to capture data, submit reports, and access project information in real-time. This streamlines workflows and eliminates data silos, as highlighted by a reviewer who credited the app with improving efficiency and reducing rework. Procore's reporting and analytics tools are also seen as valuable assets. Users appreciate the ability to generate customizable reports and dashboards, providing valuable insights into project performance, resource allocation, and potential risks. This data-driven approach helps users make informed decisions and improve overall project outcomes. However, some users mention a steeper learning curve compared to more basic software, requiring initial investment in training and user adoption. Additionally, Procore's pricing structure can be a barrier for smaller companies or those with limited budgets, while competitors might offer more affordable options with similar core functionalities. In conclusion, Procore's strengths lie in its ability to centralize data, improve communication, and streamline workflows, making it a valuable tool for complex projects and larger teams. However, its learning curve and cost might pose challenges for smaller companies or those seeking basic functionalities. Ultimately, the decision depends on individual needs, project complexity, and budget considerations.

Show more

CMiC is a comprehensive construction management software that has garnered a range of user feedback over the past year. Users appreciate its robust functionality, particularly in areas like job costing, budgeting, and document management. The software's ability to handle complex projects with multiple phases and stakeholders is a significant advantage. CMiC's integration capabilities with other software platforms are also highlighted as a strength, allowing for seamless data flow and collaboration. However, some users find the interface to be complex and overwhelming, requiring extensive training and support. The learning curve can be steep, especially for those new to construction management software. Additionally, CMiC's pricing structure can be a barrier for smaller companies, as it is often considered an enterprise-level solution. Compared to competitors like Procore and PlanGrid, CMiC offers a more comprehensive suite of features, covering the entire project lifecycle from preconstruction to closeout. Its strength lies in its ability to handle the financial aspects of construction projects, with advanced job costing and accounting tools. However, Procore and PlanGrid are often praised for their user-friendly interfaces and mobile accessibility, making them more suitable for field teams. Ultimately, CMiC is best suited for large construction companies with complex projects and dedicated IT resources to manage the software's implementation and ongoing support. Its comprehensive functionality and financial management capabilities make it a valuable tool for organizations that require a high level of control and visibility over their construction projects.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in Construction Management Software


Aconex

Buildertrend

CMiC

CoConstruct

Construction Cloud

ConstructionOnline

Contractor Foreman

e-Builder

eSUB

Fieldwire

Jonas Construction Software

PASKR

Raken

RedTeam

Sage 300 Construction

Related Categories

Head-to-Head Comparison

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
Table settings